Tesla Withholds FSD Crash Data From Prosecutors in Fatal Illinois Turn Case
Machine-coded, not yet reviewed. Spot a mistake? Email a correction.
What coverage reports
On March 25, 2026, a Tesla Model Y turning left at an intersection in Batavia struck a Dodge pickup; a Nissan SUV was also involved. A front-seat passenger in the Tesla died, and the driver and two others were reported injured. Electrek says Tesla’s filing marked the driver-assistance system as verified engaged; police said the crash remained under investigation and under review by the county State’s Attorney’s Office, with no charges filed.
Machine-drafted from the reports listed below.
BREAKING — 1h ago Tesla's own crash telemetry has confirmed that Full Self-Driving was engaged during a fatal Model Y collision in Batavia, Illinois — a March 25, 2026 left-turn crash that killed 37-year-old Maggie Espinosa, a front-seat…
Coded variables
Each value is followed by the passage it rests on. “Not stated” means the reports read did not say; it does not mean no. Definitions are in the codebook.
Incident
Incident dateincident_date | March 25, 2026 “Around 4:19 p.m. on March 25, 2026, a Tesla Model Y heading south on Randall Road” source |
|---|---|
Type of incidentincident_type | Collision “A Tesla Model Y turning left at an intersection collided with a pickup truck” source |
Collided withcollision_with | Passenger vehicle “collided with a pickup truck in Batavia, Illinois” source |
Vehicle makevehicle_make | Tesla “a Tesla Model Y heading south on Randall Road” source |
Vehicle modelvehicle_model | Model Y “a Tesla Model Y heading south on Randall Road” source |
Model yearvehicle_model_year | 2026 “Tesla marks the automation “Engagement Status” as “Verified Engaged,” and lists the 2026 Model Y’s pre-crash movement” source |
Place and time
City or localitylocation_city | Batavia “a Tesla Model Y turning left at an intersection collided with a pickup truck in Batavia, Illinois” source |
|---|---|
State or regionlocation_state_region | Illinois “collided with a pickup truck in Batavia, Illinois” source |
Countrylocation_country | Not stated in the reports read |
Road settingroad_type | Intersection “at an intersection.” source |
Time of daytime_of_day | Daytime “Around 4:19 p.m. on March 25, 2026” source |
Automation
Automated-driving feature namedsystem_named | Autopilot; Full Self-Driving “there was no mention of Autopilot, “Full Self-Driving,” or any driver-assist system.” source |
|---|---|
Was the feature in use?engagement_status | Confirmed by official source “Tesla marks the automation “Engagement Status” as “Verified Engaged,” source |
Who says it was in useengagement_claimed_by | Manufacturer; News outlet “Tesla’s own report to federal regulators says the car’s driver-assist system was engaged as it made that turn.” source |
Someone in the driver's seatdriver_seat_occupied | Yes “The Tesla’s driver and two others were injured.” source |
Driver condition mentioneddriver_condition_mentioned | Not stated in the reports read |
Harm
Deaths reportedfatalities | 1 “killing a passenger in the Tesla” source |
|---|---|
Injuries reportedinjuries | 3 “The Tesla’s driver and two others were injured.” source |
Who was harmedpersons_harmed | Subject vehicle driver; Subject vehicle passenger “The Tesla’s driver and two others were injured.” source |
Official response
Police actionpolice_action | Investigating “the crash “remains under investigation and is currently under review by the Kane County State’s Attorney’s Office.” source |
|---|---|
Criminal chargescriminal_charges | Not stated in the reports read |
Criminal case stagecriminal_case_stage | Not stated in the reports read |
Civil litigationcivil_litigation | Not stated in the reports read |
Regulator or safety boardregulator_involved | NHTSA “Tesla's own mandatory report to NHTSA confirms the car's driver-assistance system was active” source |
Responsibility attributed toresponsibility_attributed_to | Not stated in the reports read |
Coverage
Stage of coveragecoverage_stage | Follow up investigation “The Batavia Police Department's investigation remains open” source |
|---|
Who says what
- Manufacturer · Automation engagedTesla’s filing marked the driver-assistance system as verified engaged.“Tesla marks the automation “Engagement Status” as “Verified Engaged,” source
- Police · OtherPolice said the crash remained under investigation and was under review by the county State’s Attorney’s Office.“remains under investigation and is currently under review by the Kane County State’s Attorney’s Office.” source
Sources
About this record
Coded by OpenAI gpt-6-luna on November 22, 2026, codebook version 0.1. 0 proposed values were removed because the supporting passage could not be found in the report.
Cite as: CrimConsortium. Self-Driving Incidents Explorer, case SDI-00039. https://selfdriving.crimconsortium.com/cases/SDI-00039.html