Tesla Model S · Contra Costa County, CaliforniaFebruary 18, 2023

Tesla Keeps Settling Fatal Autopilot Lawsuits Right Before Trial — And That's Not an Accident

Headline from Yahoo Finance · 6 reports · first reported September 2, 2026 · record updated November 22, 2026

Autopilot mentioned in coverage1 death reported1 injury reported

Machine-coded, not yet reviewed. Spot a mistake? Email a correction.

What coverage reports

On February 18, 2023, a Tesla Model S struck a fire truck parked across Interstate 680 in Contra Costa County, California. The driver was killed and a passenger in the car was seriously injured. The family's lawsuit said Autopilot had been active before the crash and argued that the system and its marketing were deficient; Tesla contested the claims and said the driver had ignored warnings. Tesla later settled the lawsuit, and the reports say a judge had allowed the family's claims to proceed.

Machine-drafted from the reports listed below.

Tesla didn't just settle a wrongful-death lawsuit this week. It settled a case that was about to put a single word on trial — not a sensor, not a software build, not a line of code, but the word "Autopilot" itself.

Publisher's summary, Yahoo Finance

Coded variables

Each value is followed by the passage it rests on. “Not stated” means the reports read did not say; it does not mean no. Definitions are in the codebook.

Incident

Incident dateincident_dateFebruary 18, 2023
“The crash happened on February 18, 2023” source
Type of incidentincident_typeCollision
“crash in which a Model S on Autopilot slammed into a parked fire truck” source
Collided withcollision_withEmergency or police vehicle
“a county ladder fire truck parked across lanes” source
Vehicle makevehicle_makeTesla
“his 2014 Tesla Model S” source
Vehicle modelvehicle_modelModel S
“his 2014 Tesla Model S” source
Model yearvehicle_model_year2014
“his 2014 Tesla Model S” source

Place and time

City or localitylocation_cityContra Costa County
“in Contra Costa County, California” source
State or regionlocation_state_regionCalifornia
“in Contra Costa County, California” source
Countrylocation_countryUnited States
“U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California” source
Road settingroad_typeHighway or freeway
“on Interstate 680 in Contra Costa County” source
Time of daytime_of_dayNight
“a stationary vehicle in the roadway, and a car that never slowed down” source

Automation

Automated-driving feature namedsystem_namedAutopilot
“with Autopilot engaged” source
Was the feature in use?engagement_statusNot stated in the reports read
Who says it was in useengagement_claimed_byNot stated in the reports read
Someone in the driver's seatdriver_seat_occupiedYes
“[name] was driving his 2014 Tesla Model S” source
Driver condition mentioneddriver_condition_mentionedNot stated in the reports read

Harm

Deaths reportedfatalities1
“killing the driver” source
Injuries reportedinjuries1
“his brother in the passenger seat suffered serious injuries” source
Who was harmedpersons_harmedSubject vehicle driver; Subject vehicle passenger
“his brother in the passenger seat suffered serious injuries” source

Official response

Police actionpolice_actionNot stated in the reports read
Criminal chargescriminal_chargesNot stated in the reports read
Criminal case stagecriminal_case_stageNot stated in the reports read
Civil litigationcivil_litigationSettled
“Tesla has settled a wrongful death lawsuit” source
Regulator or safety boardregulator_involvedNot stated in the reports read
Responsibility attributed toresponsibility_attributed_toAutomation or manufacturer
“the gap between the marketing and the machine is what put [name] behind the wheel with more confidence than the technology deserved.” source

Coverage

Stage of coveragecoverage_stageLegal proceeding
“Tesla has settled a wrongful death lawsuit over a 2023 crash” source

Who says what

  • Plaintiff or plaintiff lawyer · Automation performance
    The lawsuit said the driver would not have been killed if the system had performed as advertised.
    “would not have been killed had the system performed as advertised.” source
  • Manufacturer · Driver behavior
    Tesla said the driver ignored warnings in the manual and warnings inside the vehicle.
    “Tesla fiercely contested the claims, saying it wasn't at fault given that [name] had ignored warnings in the owner's manual and active warnings while inside the vehicle.” source
  • Court or jury · Other
    The judge found the Autopilot name plausibly misleading.
    “the 'Autopilot' name was "plausibly misleading.” source

Sources

About this record

Coded by OpenAI gpt-6-luna on November 22, 2026, codebook version 0.1. 3 proposed values were removed because the supporting passage could not be found in the report.

Cite as: CrimConsortium. Self-Driving Incidents Explorer, case SDI-00031. https://selfdriving.crimconsortium.com/cases/SDI-00031.html