Tesla Keeps Settling Fatal Autopilot Lawsuits Right Before Trial — And That's Not an Accident
Machine-coded, not yet reviewed. Spot a mistake? Email a correction.
What coverage reports
On February 18, 2023, a Tesla Model S struck a fire truck parked across Interstate 680 in Contra Costa County, California. The driver was killed and a passenger in the car was seriously injured. The family's lawsuit said Autopilot had been active before the crash and argued that the system and its marketing were deficient; Tesla contested the claims and said the driver had ignored warnings. Tesla later settled the lawsuit, and the reports say a judge had allowed the family's claims to proceed.
Machine-drafted from the reports listed below.
Tesla didn't just settle a wrongful-death lawsuit this week. It settled a case that was about to put a single word on trial — not a sensor, not a software build, not a line of code, but the word "Autopilot" itself.
Coded variables
Each value is followed by the passage it rests on. “Not stated” means the reports read did not say; it does not mean no. Definitions are in the codebook.
Incident
Incident dateincident_date | February 18, 2023 “The crash happened on February 18, 2023” source |
|---|---|
Type of incidentincident_type | Collision “crash in which a Model S on Autopilot slammed into a parked fire truck” source |
Collided withcollision_with | Emergency or police vehicle “a county ladder fire truck parked across lanes” source |
Vehicle makevehicle_make | Tesla “his 2014 Tesla Model S” source |
Vehicle modelvehicle_model | Model S “his 2014 Tesla Model S” source |
Model yearvehicle_model_year | 2014 “his 2014 Tesla Model S” source |
Place and time
City or localitylocation_city | Contra Costa County “in Contra Costa County, California” source |
|---|---|
State or regionlocation_state_region | California “in Contra Costa County, California” source |
Countrylocation_country | United States “U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California” source |
Road settingroad_type | Highway or freeway “on Interstate 680 in Contra Costa County” source |
Time of daytime_of_day | Night “a stationary vehicle in the roadway, and a car that never slowed down” source |
Automation
Automated-driving feature namedsystem_named | Autopilot “with Autopilot engaged” source |
|---|---|
Was the feature in use?engagement_status | Not stated in the reports read |
Who says it was in useengagement_claimed_by | Not stated in the reports read |
Someone in the driver's seatdriver_seat_occupied | Yes “[name] was driving his 2014 Tesla Model S” source |
Driver condition mentioneddriver_condition_mentioned | Not stated in the reports read |
Harm
Deaths reportedfatalities | 1 “killing the driver” source |
|---|---|
Injuries reportedinjuries | 1 “his brother in the passenger seat suffered serious injuries” source |
Who was harmedpersons_harmed | Subject vehicle driver; Subject vehicle passenger “his brother in the passenger seat suffered serious injuries” source |
Official response
Police actionpolice_action | Not stated in the reports read |
|---|---|
Criminal chargescriminal_charges | Not stated in the reports read |
Criminal case stagecriminal_case_stage | Not stated in the reports read |
Civil litigationcivil_litigation | Settled “Tesla has settled a wrongful death lawsuit” source |
Regulator or safety boardregulator_involved | Not stated in the reports read |
Responsibility attributed toresponsibility_attributed_to | Automation or manufacturer “the gap between the marketing and the machine is what put [name] behind the wheel with more confidence than the technology deserved.” source |
Coverage
Stage of coveragecoverage_stage | Legal proceeding “Tesla has settled a wrongful death lawsuit over a 2023 crash” source |
|---|
Who says what
- Plaintiff or plaintiff lawyer · Automation performanceThe lawsuit said the driver would not have been killed if the system had performed as advertised.“would not have been killed had the system performed as advertised.” source
- Manufacturer · Driver behaviorTesla said the driver ignored warnings in the manual and warnings inside the vehicle.“Tesla fiercely contested the claims, saying it wasn't at fault given that [name] had ignored warnings in the owner's manual and active warnings while inside the vehicle.” source
- Court or jury · OtherThe judge found the Autopilot name plausibly misleading.“the 'Autopilot' name was "plausibly misleading.” source
Sources
About this record
Coded by OpenAI gpt-6-luna on November 22, 2026, codebook version 0.1. 3 proposed values were removed because the supporting passage could not be found in the report.
Cite as: CrimConsortium. Self-Driving Incidents Explorer, case SDI-00031. https://selfdriving.crimconsortium.com/cases/SDI-00031.html