Tesla Challenges $243 Million Florida Crash Verdict, Says Driver Ignored Autopilot Warnings
Machine-coded, not yet reviewed. Spot a mistake? Email a correction.
What coverage reports
On April 25, 2019, a 2019 Tesla Model S with Autopilot engaged ran a stop sign at about 62 mph at a T-intersection on Card Sound Road near Key Largo, Florida, and struck a parked SUV, which hit two people standing nearby; one was killed and one seriously injured. The driver, who had looked down to retrieve a dropped phone, was cited for careless driving and pleaded no contest, with adjudication withheld. In August 2025 a federal jury found Tesla 33% responsible; Tesla's share of the judgment is about $243 million. Tesla filed an appeal brief on November 6, 2026, arguing the distracted driver caused the crash; the appeals court has not ruled.
Machine-drafted from the reports listed below.
Tesla is asking a federal appeals court to overturn a $243 million judgment stemming from a fatal Florida Keys crash, arguing that a distracted driver, rather than defects in its Autopilot system, ...
Coded variables
Each value is followed by the passage it rests on. “Not stated” means the reports read did not say; it does not mean no. Definitions are in the codebook.
Incident
Incident dateincident_date | April 25, 2019 “The case dates to April 25, 2019, when a Tesla Model S ran through a stop sign at approximately 62 mph and struck a parked Chevrolet Tahoe.” source |
|---|---|
Type of incidentincident_type | Collision “The case dates to April 25, 2019, when a Tesla Model S ran through a stop sign at approximately 62 mph and struck a parked Chevrolet Tahoe.” source |
Collided withcollision_with | Passenger vehicle; Pedestrian “struck the parked Tahoe. ... who were standing nearby” source |
Vehicle makevehicle_make | Tesla “The case dates to April 25, 2019, when a Tesla Model S ran through a stop sign at approximately 62 mph and struck a parked Chevrolet Tahoe.” source |
Vehicle modelvehicle_model | Model S “The case dates to April 25, 2019, when a Tesla Model S ran through a stop sign at approximately 62 mph and struck a parked Chevrolet Tahoe.” source |
Model yearvehicle_model_year | 2019 “driving his 2019 Tesla Model S on Card Sound Road near Key Largo shortly after 9 p.m.” source |
Place and time
City or localitylocation_city | Key Largo “driving his 2019 Tesla Model S on Card Sound Road near Key Largo shortly after 9 p.m.” source |
|---|---|
State or regionlocation_state_region | Florida “a $243 million judgment stemming from a fatal Florida Keys crash” source |
Countrylocation_country | United States “a $243 million judgment stemming from a fatal Florida Keys crash” source |
Road settingroad_type | Intersection “With Autopilot engaged, the vehicle continued toward a T-intersection, passed through a stop sign, and struck the parked Tahoe.” source |
Time of daytime_of_day | Night “driving his 2019 Tesla Model S on Card Sound Road near Key Largo shortly after 9 p.m.” source |
Automation
Automated-driving feature namedsystem_named | Autopilot “With Autopilot engaged, the vehicle continued toward a T-intersection, passed through a stop sign, and struck the parked Tahoe.” source |
|---|---|
Was the feature in use?engagement_status | Confirmed by official source “With Autopilot engaged, the vehicle continued toward a T-intersection, passed through a stop sign, and struck the parked Tahoe.” source |
Who says it was in useengagement_claimed_by | Driver; Plaintiff or plaintiff lawyer; Court or jury “would not have taken his eyes off the road if he had been driving without the system engaged” source |
Someone in the driver's seatdriver_seat_occupied | Yes “he dropped his cellphone and looked down to retrieve it” source |
Driver condition mentioneddriver_condition_mentioned | Distracted “he dropped his cellphone and looked down to retrieve it” source |
Harm
Deaths reportedfatalities | 1 “The collision killed 22-year-old [name] and seriously injured her boyfriend” source |
|---|---|
Injuries reportedinjuries | 1 “The collision killed 22-year-old [name] and seriously injured her boyfriend” source |
Who was harmedpersons_harmed | Pedestrian “who were standing nearby” source |
Official response
Police actionpolice_action | Citation issued “was cited for careless driving following the fatal crash” source |
|---|---|
Criminal chargescriminal_charges | Not stated in the reports read |
Criminal case stagecriminal_case_stage | Not stated in the reports read |
Civil litigationcivil_litigation | Verdict for plaintiff “A federal jury found Tesla 33% responsible for the crash in August 2025, assigning the remaining 67% to driver” source |
Regulator or safety boardregulator_involved | Not stated in the reports read |
Responsibility attributed toresponsibility_attributed_to | Driver; Automation or manufacturer “A federal jury found Tesla 33% responsible for the crash in August 2025, assigning the remaining 67% to driver” source |
Coverage
Stage of coveragecoverage_stage | Legal proceeding “The company filed its latest brief with the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit on November 6, 2026.” source |
|---|
Who says what
- Court or jury · Cause or responsibilityIn August 2025 a federal jury found Tesla 33% responsible and the driver 67% responsible, and added $200 million in punitive damages against Tesla.“A federal jury found Tesla 33% responsible for the crash in August 2025, assigning the remaining 67% to driver” source
- Manufacturer · Cause or responsibilityIn its appeal, Tesla argues that a distracted driver, not a defect in Autopilot, caused the collision.“arguing that a distracted driver, rather than defects in its Autopilot system, caused the collision” source
- Manufacturer · Driver behaviorTesla says the driver was pressing the accelerator and that the car displayed a message that cruise control would not brake while the accelerator was pressed.“Tesla says the car displayed a message explaining that cruise control would not brake while the accelerator was pressed” source
- Plaintiff or plaintiff lawyer · Automation performanceThe plaintiffs' lawyers say crash data showed the car detected the parked SUV and a pedestrian but did not warn the driver or brake.“crash data showed the Tesla detected the parked SUV and a pedestrian but failed to warn” source
- Plaintiff or plaintiff lawyer · Cause or responsibilityThe plaintiffs argue Tesla encouraged excessive trust in Autopilot without adequate safeguards.“The plaintiffs argue that the company encouraged excessive trust in Autopilot while failing to implement adequate safeguards.” source
- Driver · Driver behaviorThe driver accepted he was responsible for controlling the car, and testified that he trusted Autopilot too much and would not have looked away without it engaged.“he also testified that he trusted Autopilot too much and would not have taken his eyes off the road if he had been driving without the system engaged” source
Sources
About this record
Coded by Claude Fable 5.2 (Perplexity Computer), initial batch on November 22, 2026, codebook version 0.1. 0 proposed values were removed because the supporting passage could not be found in the report.
Cite as: CrimConsortium. Self-Driving Incidents Explorer, case SDI-00005. https://selfdriving.crimconsortium.com/cases/SDI-00005.html